CJ Abrams put together a steadier 2025 campaign after an unusual ending to his first All-Star season in 2024, when the Nationals briefly optioned him to Triple-A following a curfew-related disciplinary issue in September. He avoided any similar distractions last year and remained largely productive when available.
Abrams did miss a short stretch in April with a right hip flexor strain, but he still nearly delivered his second consecutive 20-30 season, finishing just one home run short of 20.
The sixth overall pick in 2019 and centerpiece of Washington’s return in the 2022 Juan Soto deal has now accumulated 6.9 fWAR (FanGraphs’ Wins Above Replacement) across his first four major league seasons, though his overall value continues to be weighed down by unfavorable defensive metrics at shortstop. Notably, his expected batting average has remained essentially unchanged over the last three seasons, holding in a narrow .247 to .248 range.
Fantasy Baseball: Strengths, Weaknesses and 2026 Projection
Abrams’ fantasy appeal remains driven by his rare speed and improving power blend at a premium position. His ability to impact the game on the bases gives him a strong weekly scoring floor in Fantasy Baseball Points Leagues, particularly when he is getting on base consistently near the top of the lineup.
Abrams also continues to show enough pop to keep pitchers honest, making him a multi-category contributor even when the batting average stabilizes in the mid-.240s range.
The concerns are tied to his overall offensive ceiling and defensive profile. The lack of growth in expected batting average suggests his hit tool may be leveling off, and the defensive metrics at shortstop remain a drag on his real-life value. There is also some volatility tied to his aggressive approach, which can lead to streaky stretches at the plate. If the on-base skills do not take another step forward, his Points League ceiling could remain capped compared to the elite tier.
From a Fantasy Baseball Points League perspective, Abrams still profiles as a valuable Tier 3 shortstop entering 2026. His combination of speed, emerging power and everyday role keeps him firmly in the upper-middle tier at the position.
A reasonable projection for 2026 includes another near 20-30 caliber season with solid counting stats, though a true breakout into the elite tier will likely require measurable growth in plate discipline and overall contact quality.
As far as shortstop hierarchy for Fantasy Baseball Points Leagues, I rank him at Tier 3 under Bobby Witt Jr., Elly De La Cruz and Gunnar Henderson, among others and higher than Jeremy Peña, Geraldo Perdomo and Corey Seager.
Leave a Reply