Hunter Goodman emerged as one of the few bright spots for Colorado in 2025, delivering a breakout that caught many fantasy managers off guard. The power was never in question after he launched 36 home runs in 2022 and 34 in 2023 across the Rockies’ farm system, but skepticism remained following his difficult major league showing in 2024.
Goodman answered many of those concerns by translating his minor league pop into meaningful major league production.
The Rockies’ constantly shifting depth chart once again created opportunity, and Goodman capitalized early. He opened the season strong and proceeded to hit home runs consistently over the course of the season.
He also made modest improvements in his strikeout rate (K%) while drawing more walks, a positive development for points league formats. Notably, 18 of his 31 home runs came away from Coors Field, reinforcing that his power plays in any environment.
Hunter Goodman’s Strengths, Weaknesses, and 2026 Fantasy Baseball Projections
Goodman’s primary strength is legitimate, game-ready power that now appears less park-dependent than initially believed. His ability to produce consistently throughout the season and contribute across multiple categories makes him particularly appealing in fantasy baseball points leagues. The incremental gains in plate discipline also hint at a hitter who may still have room to grow offensively.
The concerns center on sustainability and batting average volatility. His .307 average at home compared to .248 on the road highlights some environmental dependence, and his overall hit tool still carries risk if the contact gains stall. Additionally, Colorado’s fluid roster usage could occasionally impact his volume depending on how the club deploys its pieces.
Entering 2026, Goodman profiles as a power-forward catcher with meaningful upside if the plate skills continue trending in the right direction. In fantasy baseball points league formats, he projects as a strong mid-tier option capable of delivering 25 to 30 home runs with useful counting stats, though managers should still expect some batting average swings along the way.
He also benefits from Colorado’s favorable offensive environment and lineup opportunity. Continued growth in approach and contact quality would give him a realistic path toward outperforming his current valuation significantly.
As far as catcher hierarchy for fantasy baseball points leagues, I rank him at Tier 3 under Cal Raleigh, Ben Rice, and William Contreras, among others, and higher than Drake Baldwin, Will Smith, and Salvador Perez.
Leave a Reply